Token types: ERC-20, BEP-20, TRC-20 & SPL. What’s the difference?

The same familiar token name can appear under different standards on different networks. This comparison explains ERC-20, BEP-20, TRC-20 and SPL through compatibility, transfer support and transaction costs.

Why are there different crypto token standards?

A token standard defines interfaces and behavior that compatible software can use. It does not certify the issuer, the asset’s value or support on a different blockchain.

Being a subset of smart contract standards, token guidelines are crucial for blockchains with smart contract capabilities, steering the creation and deployment of new tokens. These standards are vital for tracking token performance and efficiency, assuring their interoperability and integration with existing applications.

What are the main types of crypto token standards?

Different blockchains often introduce various token standards to standardize the functions and parameters of tokens on their platforms. The list of token types is constantly growing and evolving but here are the main four we will focus on:

ERC-20, BEP-20, and TRC-20 define fungible-token interfaces on their respective networks; the number 20 does not mean “regular coins.” ERC-721 and TRC-721 cover NFTs, while ERC-1155 can represent multiple fungible and non-fungible token types. TRC-10 is a separate TRON token standard. Native coins such as ETH, BNB, TRX, and SOL are distinct from these token standards.

What are the key differences?

ERC-20 is the fungible-token interface used on Ethereum; BEP-20 is used on BNB Smart Chain; TRC-20 is used on TRON; and SPL tokens use Solana Token Programs. Ethereum fees use ETH, BSC fees use BNB, and Solana fees use SOL. TRON uses Bandwidth and Energy, with TRX burned when required resources are unavailable. Fees and confirmation times vary, and none of these standards provides a universal security rating or an automatic route between networks.

Fees, confirmation times, and security are properties of the network, token implementation, and service you use, not guarantees made by a token standard. Compare the actual network and transaction before sending. The sections below explain the individual standards in more detail.

ERC-20 Token Standard

ERC stands for Ethereum Request for Comments. ERC-20 defines a common interface for fungible tokens, including transfers, balances, and spending allowances. Ethereum also has other token standards, such as ERC-721 for NFTs; not every Ethereum asset is an ERC-20 token.

Similar interfaces do not make balances interchangeable between blockchains. A token deployed on Ethereum and a version deployed on BNB Smart Chain or TRON have separate contracts and balances. Moving value between them requires a supported bridge, issuer mechanism, or exchange withdrawal on the correct network. Verify the destination network and the exact token before transferring.

A distributed validator set can tolerate specified failures under the network’s consensus assumptions. The number of validators alone does not guarantee resilience to every outage or attack.

Advantages:

  1. Maturity: Being one of the first token standards, it has a well-established and tested environment.

  2. Wide Acceptance: Supported by almost all exchanges, wallets, and many Dapps.

  3. Decentralization: Ethereum is widely recognized for its decentralized nature.

  4. Development Community: Large developer community and extensive resources/documentation available.

Disadvantages:

  1. High Gas Fees: Especially during network congestion.

  2. Scalability: The Ethereum network can get congested with high transaction volumes.

  3. Upgrade Risk: Deployed contract code is immutable, but proxy-based tokens can change the logic they execute. Check who controls upgrades and other privileged functions.

BEP-20 Token Standard

BEP-20 is a fungible-token standard on BNB Smart Chain (BSC), closely modeled on ERC-20. It defines operations such as transferring tokens, checking balances, and granting spending allowances. BSC also supports other asset types; not every asset on BSC is a BEP-20 token.

BSC is an EVM-compatible blockchain, so developers can reuse many Ethereum tools and contract patterns. This does not transfer an existing Ethereum balance to BSC. BEP-20 versions of assets such as BTC or ETH are separate representations whose backing and redemption depend on their issuer or bridge. A matching address format does not prove that a receiving service supports the network or asset.

BEP-20 makes it easier for BSC applications to integrate a common token interface. Wallet and exchange support still needs to be checked for each token and network. Compatibility with Ethereum development tools does not automatically make a BSC token usable in an Ethereum application.

For a supported token such as a network-specific version of USDT, fees and transfer times depend on the network and service used. Check the recipient’s deposit instructions and token contract, and make a small test transfer when practical. A bridge adds its own smart-contract, custody, and liquidity risks.

Advantages:

  1. Low Transaction Fees: Significantly cheaper transactions than Ethereum.

  2. Fast Transactions: Speedy processing times.

  3. Compatibility: Compatible with Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM).

  4. Backing by Binance: Supported and promoted by one of the largest cryptocurrency exchanges.

Disadvantages:

  1. Centralization Concerns: Binance holds a significant influence over BSC, leading to centralization worries.

  2. Younger Ecosystem: Though rapidly growing, it's still newer and less established than Ethereum.

TRC-20 Token Standard

TRC-20 is a standard for tokens on the TRON blockchain, defining their issuance, transfer, and other rules. Much like Ethereum's ERC-20 tokens, TRC-20 tokens offer speedy and secure transactions on the TRON network, playing pivotal roles in various TRON dApps, spanning gaming, finance, social media, and beyond.

TRON is a separate blockchain that supports smart contracts. TRC-20 defines a common interface for fungible tokens. Compatibility depends on whether a receiving wallet or application supports the specific token contract; fees and confirmation times vary.

Unlike Ethereum's proof-of-stake (PoS) consensus, TRON employs the more efficient delegated proof-of-stake (DPoS), marked by rapid transactions and cost-effectiveness, backed by numerous nodes and tailored innovations.

Though TRC-20 tokens, like USDT (TRC-20), are celebrated for their speed and affordability, they remain less sought-after compared to their Ethereum counterparts.

Advantages:

  1. Low Fees: Cost-effective transactions compared to Ethereum.

  2. High Throughput: Faster transaction speeds due to the DPoS consensus mechanism.

  3. Growing Ecosystem: Rapidly expanding Dapp and token ecosystem.

Disadvantages:

  1. Lesser Adoption: Compared to ERC-20 tokens, there's lesser market adoption for TRC-20 tokens.

  2. Centralization Concerns: Some critiques point to a more centralized node/validation system compared to Ethereum.

SPL Token Standard

Solana is a high-performance blockchain platform designed to support decentralized apps and crypto projects at scale. The Solana protocol is known for its fast transaction speeds and low costs, making it an attractive platform for developers and projects.

SPL means Solana Program Library. Solana tokens use Token Programs that manage minting, transfers, balances, and authorities. The original Token Program and the newer Token Extensions Program (Token-2022) support different capabilities; wallets and applications must support the specific program and extensions used by a token.

Developers can use the SPL Token standard to create their own custom tokens on the Solana blockchain. Just like how Ethereum's ERC-20 standard led to a proliferation of various tokens and projects on the Ethereum network, the SPL token standard serves a similar function for the Solana ecosystem.

Advantages:

  1. Ultra-fast: Solana's unique architecture allows for sub-second transaction times.

  2. Low Fees: Even with high transaction volumes, fees remain low.

  3. Scalability: Designed to handle a large number of transactions per second.

Disadvantages:

  1. New Ecosystem: Being relatively newer, it's still building its ecosystem compared to Ethereum.

  2. Adoption: Not as widely recognized or adopted as ERC-20 tokens yet.

  3. Development Community: While growing, it's still smaller compared to Ethereum's.

What token standards does Unitywallet currently support?

At the time of writing this piece, Unitywallet supports ERC-20, BEP-20, TRC-20 & SPL token types with plans to integrate more in the nearest future.

Closing thoughts

ERC-20, BEP-20, TRC-20 and SPL describe different network contexts. Before transferring, establish the asset, contract and recipient’s supported network; matching names and address formats are not enough.


Sources: Blockchain bridges; ERC-1155; ERC-20; TRC-20; Solana tokens

Share this article

GET THE APP

Your move starts here.

Scan the code, or pick your store below.

Opens the right store for your phone

or

GET THE APP

Your move starts here.

Scan the code, or pick your store below.

Opens the right store for your phone

or